banana cream pie or pudding

A Paleo banana cream pie! All the Thanksgiving feels on this one – another pie that I used to make every year with my mom for the holidays. Back in the day, the filling was certainly from a box of J-E-L-L-O brand pudding mix, but the sentiment and crust was always homemade!

Since I know not everyone has access to or can even tolerate raw milk like we do, I’ve tested this paleo banana cream pie recipe out using some non dairy options and it worked out wonderfully! Which makes me so very happy!!! The sub I used for the raw milk was the cashew milk paste from AddJoi – with a ratio of 3 tblsp paste to 10 oz of water. The whipped cream (not paleo, but is dairy free) is the cocowhip from So-Delicious, literally, so delicious!

banana cream pie

If you don’t want to go all out and make the pie, make the filling and spoon into dessert cups, truly still amazing and festive!

pie crust mix
our PIE CRUST MIX is now available from LEGIT BREAD COMPANY!

Here’s some links for you:
our Paleo Pie Crust recipe
Maple sugar we use: Coombs Maple Sugar
Our favorite salt: Redmond Real Salt kosher salt

Happy Thanksgiving everyone!

banana cream pie or pudding

Recipe by MichelleCourse: dessert


Prep time



a luscious cream pie that is non dairy and so delicious


  • 1 baked pie crust, see link above for our WONDERFUL recipe!!

  • 6 egg yolks

  • ½ cup maple sugar (can sub coconut sugar, flavor profile will be different & color will be darker)

  • 3 tblsp tapioca starch

  • ½ tsp Redmond Real Salt kosher salt

  • 3 tblsp grass fed butter, or ghee

  • 1½ cups raw milk, or nut milk of choice

  • 1 tsp vanilla

  • 1 cup organic whipped cream, or non dairy whipped cream

  • 1-2 ripe bananas for using on the pie and for garnish

  • 1 tblsp of fresh lemon juice (opt)


  • In a medium size saucepan, whisk together egg yolks, maple sugar, tapioca starch and salt. Set aside.
  • Place butter in a large measuring cup or bowl that you can rest a fine mesh on top of. Set aside. You’ll want to prepare this ahead of time.
  • Pour milk into a small saucepan and warm over low heat JUST until you see small bubbles around the edges (Do Not Boil!) Add this SLOWLY to the egg yolk mixture, whisking as you pour. Cook this mixture over medium heat, stirring constantly until thickened. Usually around 5-7 minutes. Remove from heat and whisk in vanilla.
  • Pour this mixture through the sieve into the large bowl with the butter. It will be thick, but use the back of a spoon or spatula to push it through. This will remove any lumps. Whisk in butter as it melts and fully combine.
  • Place in the refrigerator to cool. When ready, add whipped cream and whisk to combine, set aside.
  • If you want to add a layer of sliced banana on the baked crust, cut into ¼” discs and coat lightly with a bit of lemon juice to keep them from turning brown. Totally an optional step that’s more for aesthetics. Otherwise, pour cream mixture into the prepared pie crust and place in the refrigerator to set up. Before serving add more banana discs and whipped cream to garnish.


  1. Pingback: paleo pop tarts brown sugar cinnamon pop tarts ~ Back Porch Paleo

  2. Pingback: Paleo holiday pie holiday pumpkin pie ~ Back Porch Paleo

  3. Pingback: pear pie salted caramel pear pie ~ Back Porch Paleo

  4. Jessica Taylor

    Would arrowroot be okay in place of tapioca?

    • Hi there Jessica – sorry for the delay in getting back to you! I think you could probably use that sub as they are often subbed for each other. ~Michelle

  5. Pingback: apple hand pies glazed apple hand pies - Back Porch Paleo

  6. Pingback: mini pear pies Paleo mini pear pies - Back Porch Paleo

  7. Pingback: cherry vanilla cherry vanilla pie - Back Porch Paleo

  8. Pingback: paleo butterscotch pie paleo butterscotch pie - Back Porch Paleo

  9. Pingback: leftover dinner leftover Thanksgiving dinner hand pies - Back Porch Paleo

  10. Pingback: pear tart paleo pear tart - Back Porch Paleo

  11. Pingback: shortbread cookie cassava flour shortbread cookies - Back Porch Paleo

  12. Pingback: artichoke dip bubbly artichoke dip - Back Porch Paleo

  13. Pingback: paleo hot pockets paleo hot pockets - Back Porch Paleo

  14. Pingback: paleo fig galettes mini paleo fig & prosciutto galettes - Back Porch Paleo

  15. Pingback: pumpkin paleo pop tarts paleo pumpkin spice pop tarts - Back Porch Paleo

  16. Pingback: paleo potato galette rosemary potato galette - Back Porch Paleo

Leave a Reply